"Bigger Paychecks" or a Big Regret?
Project 2025 includes proposals to overhaul the tax system — pushing for a flat tax, eliminating the IRS, and replacing income tax with consumption taxes. Sounds revolutionary, but who really benefits?
Person Type | Flat Tax Impact |
---|---|
Low-income | Likely pay more |
Middle-income | May pay slightly more |
High-income | Likely pay less |
Families with kids | Lose all credits |
Self-employed | Lose deductions |
Current System (2024) | Flat Tax (15%) | |
---|---|---|
Gross Income | $63,000 | $63,000 |
Standard Deduction | $14,600 | None |
Taxable Income | $48,400 | $63,000 |
Total Tax Owed | $5,576 | $9,450 |
Without paycheck withholding, you’d need to manually save for your taxes. So, realistically, you’d be paying like a subcontractor. That means tracking your income, saving for taxes, and probably making estimated quarterly payments.
Now | Under Flat Tax | |
---|---|---|
Taxes withheld automatically | ✅ | ❌ |
Refund likely | ✅ | ❌ |
Must budget manually | ❌ | ✅ |
Quarterly payments required | ❌ | ✅ |
Refunds help people pay off debt, buy essentials, or catch up on bills. Dave Ramsey says you shouldn't get a refund because it means you overpaid. But if you’re a low-income parent relying on the EIC — that is free money. And it’s going away.
Dave Ramsey is a quack.
No refunds. No credits. Just a big bill waiting at the end of the year. Hope you saved!
For the first 11 months, life feels good. Then April hits and people are blindsided by a tax bill they can’t pay.
“We told you to save.” And that’s it. No help. No relief. Just penalties if you didn’t plan properly.
It’ll be in the fine print, ignored by media, and never mentioned until the first wave of panic rolls in next April.
This isn’t about fairness. It’s about erasing protections, simplifying the system for the rich, and shifting blame to individuals for struggling under new rules.